World Science Scholars
18.2 Disintegrating Muons video Back to course

You must be logged in to reply to this discussion. Sami Al-Suwailem
The numbers seem to be not accurate. Gamma = 1/sqrt(1-0.994^2) = 9.14243. Dividing 5.9 km by gamma = 0.645343 km. To obtain the speed of the muon in km/s, we divide 0.645343 km by (2.2 * 10^-6 s) = 293,338 km/s. Speed of light = 299,792 km/s. Dividing these two numbers = 293,338 / 299,792 = 0.978472. This not equal to 0.994 that we started with. Sami Al-Suwailem Marius Smallegoor
This indeed is a riddle! I agree with your calculations. Also when you calculate the time that passed on earth (2,2 * 10^-6 * gamma = 2,0113346 * 10^-5 s) and use this to calculate the speed you also get v = 5,9/2,0113346 = 293,338 km/s = 0,978C I don't see where this goes wrong because the only thing we use is 5,9 km, v=0,994C and lifetime muon in rest = 2,2*10^-6. All the rest is derived using gamma....... Marius Smallegoor
The only conclusion I can draw is that 5,9 km is wrong. When you use the time passed on Earth (2,0113346 s * 10^-5) to calculate the distance travelled according to an observer on Earth you get 2,0113346 s * 10^-5 * 299,792*0,994 = 5,9936413 km instead of 5,9 km!! Using this 5,9936413 you find 0,655585 km as the Lorentz contracted distance. And this gives you the speed v = 0,655585 / 2,2 * 10^-6 = 297,993 km/s. This is 297,993/299792 =0,994C ! Marius Smallegoor
I checked the lifetime of a muon: 2.1969811 * 10^-6. This gives you 5,9854 km (see calculations above).
×

## Share with others

Select this checkbox if you want to share this with all users Select Users

Enter the usernames or email IDs of the users you want to share with 