Forum Replies Created
-
December 16, 2020 at 11:48 pm
I have heard this before and still find it surprising, but am willing to accept it if it allows consistency with theories and calculations. But I dont find the demonstration totally convincing. Allan says there is no gravitational field inside the sphere because the force from around the sphere cancels out. But isnt this only true at the centre? Away from the centre isnt there a net force because such a point is closer to one side of the sphere? So if there is a field there before the collapse, as the field contracts it isnt the case that a field appears where there was no field before.Also what happens if the sphere collapses without generating power. The same region of supposedly no gravitational field will after collapse have the same field with out doing any work. All very interesting!
October 7, 2020 at 3:05 amNo explosion because the proper lengths of the pole and barn are such that the pole will not fit physically. The observed lengths are not the physical lengths and its the physical lengths that would be relevant to effecting an explosion event. This reminds me of Schrodingers cat!
September 17, 2020 at 8:35 pmIts always the other guy’s clock that is going slow relative to my inertial frame. So if something happens in the other guy’s frame at say 1PM it will happen at 1:01PM according to my clock. But does this mean it happens in MY past? It hasn’t happened before 1:01Pm according to me so it hasn’t happened in my past. And nothing seems to happen in my future either. So obviously my PAST is real (having experienced it) but not the other guy’s, and not my FUTURE.
September 14, 2020 at 10:21 pmWe know we are not in an inertial frame because we know we are moving due to earth’s spinning and orbiting around sun. So our velocity is changing. But your argument doesn’t apply.There is no net force on us if we sit in a chair. If we sat on a chair on a non-spinning earth floating in space we would still feel pressure from the seat, yet would be in an inertial frame.
